The official meeting between Giorgia Meloni and U.S. President Donald J. Trump at the White House was presented as an occasion to strengthen transatlantic relations. But beneath the diplomatic surface, it revealed much about the true political nature of the Italian Prime Minister. Although Trump welcomed Meloni enthusiastically, calling her a “great world leader”, it seems he may not have fully grasped who she really is.
It’s not the first time Meloni has used international exposure to rebuild a credibility she lacks at home. In the past, President Joe Biden also greeted her warmly, even playing the Italian song “Giorgia” as a symbolic gesture of welcome. Meloni responded with smiles and full alignment to the Democratic Party’s global agenda. In Italian talk shows of the time, she openly praised Kamala Harris and declared that it wouldn’t be good if Donald Trump were to win the election. A position that now contrasts sharply with the image she tries to present.
Meloni is a skilled shapeshifter—she changes her face depending on who’s in front of her. With Biden, she played the moderate, pro-NATO stateswoman. With Trump, who is against further military involvement in Ukraine, she quickly adjusted her tone, carefully avoiding any reference to her previous pro-Zelenskyy alignment. With Macron, she’s a European loyalist. With Ursula von der Leyen, she’s entirely cooperative. With Zelenskyy, she’s enthusiastic. Meloni cozies up to everyone, constantly changing her stance based on political convenience.
Let’s not forget that Giorgia Meloni firmly voted in favor of the €800 billion European rearmament package, a move that not only heightens tensions with Russia but shatters her credibility as a so-called “mediator” between the U.S. and Europe. The truth is, Meloni has never had a consistent position. Today she presents herself as a pacifier, but tomorrow—when she finds herself next to Ursula and Zelenskyy again—she’ll instantly return to their side.
She also shows no shame in denying her own promises. She was elected on pledges to lower gasoline prices, running ads claiming that out of €50 worth of gas, €35 were unjust taxes dating back to World War I and Italy’s colonial wars in Africa. But just 100 days into office—imitating the American communication style—she filmed a video with a surprised expression saying, “Did I promise to lower gas prices? I don’t remember.” A phrase that will go down in history as a symbol of her hypocrisy.
Completely opposite to Donald Trump, who since returning to the presidency in January 2025 has immediately fulfilled his promise to cut gas prices. In many U.S. cities, gas has dropped below $3 per gallon. Facts, not theatrics, distinguish a real leader from one built by the media.
Meloni is anything but a solid presence in European politics. In Sicily, we call this kind of person a “bannera ri cannavazzu”—a light, unstable flag that bends with the wind. Today she flatters Trump. Tomorrow, she’ll dress up in European colors and run back to Brussels. Just wait until the next international summit with both camps at the table to see which direction she turns. Like the unpredictable winds of sirocco and mistral that alternate violently across the Mediterranean, Meloni shifts chaotically, like an intersection with no signs—completely unable to choose a direction.
Italian journalists at the White House tried to expose the truth behind Meloni’s double-faced stance, particularly on Ukraine. One journalist asked her directly about Trump’s belief that Zelenskyy is to blame for the war. Meloni, visibly nervous, avoided answering and let her interpreter speak instead. After a brief hesitation, she checked her phone, and only then attempted a response—clearly guided by live instructions. This behavior reinforced the image of a politician lacking substance and independence.
This isn’t an isolated case. Meloni is known for constantly shifting alliances and opinions. With von der Leyen and Macron, she presents herself as a loyal supporter of EU agendas, fully backing billion-euro defense projects and Brussels’ bureaucratic vision.
Meloni’s political inconsistency raises serious doubts about her credibility as Italy’s representative on the international stage. It’s evident that she will betray any promise to cling to power. Her visit to the White House was not about diplomacy—it was about building international legitimacy that she lacks in Italy. In fact, at every public rally, she’s now met with increasing hostility, especially from mothers who accuse her of betraying families. A far cry from the “world leader” President Trump believes her to be.
A striking moment came when she turned to Trump with a forced smile and said: “Sorry if I’m using this moment to advertise my government, but you understand, you’re a businessman.” Trump didn’t smile. Instead, he turned his gaze away, as if to say: “Who do you think you’re fooling?” And he closed the moment with a sharp remark: “Thanks, but we want to solve problems,” drawing a clear line between action and empty words.
Conclusion
President Trump should take a closer look at who his true allies are in Europe. There is only one truly consistent partner: Viktor Orbán, Prime Minister of Hungary. Orbán has openly adopted Trump-style policies, fighting illegal immigration, resisting gender ideology, and opposing EU overreach.
Most importantly, Orbán doesn’t wear multiple faces at once. Unlike Giorgia Meloni, who behaves like a true “cascavaddu”, a Sicilian word for someone who flips positions constantly based on self-interest.
Donald Trump would be wise to beware the political falsehoods of Giorgia Meloni. Behind the smiles and flattering words, there is only propaganda, contradiction, and opportunism.
And from Sicilia Indipendente, we say this with respect and clarity:
Mr. Trump, we are truly disappointed that such a figure might be seen as a leader. She may be a leader—but only of lies.